Monday, March 18, 2013

Imagining the Nokia tablet Revamped


Credit for image goes to Jonas Daehnert

The original article grew to near mammoth proportions in length in terms of usual Internet standards. Here's my revamped take on the subject, but the original blog post can be read beneath this one for those interested in the details behind my ideas.

Nokia faces notable challenges in introducing a tablet of its own. One of these challenges is Samsung's and Apple's dominance in the tablet market. In this relatively flooded market of tablets, Nokia has to design a tablet that stands out in form factor and design, hardware and software, but also in use purpose as well, I argue. Nokia has to innovate and bring a new spin to how we use tablets.


The operating system

Nokia's only real option is Windows RT. As much as I'd like to fantasize about a MeeGo powered tablet, if Nokia wouldn't perfect their awesome MeeGo-Harmattan platform for their iconic N9, they haven't perfected it for tablet use either. Full Windows 8 poses technical problems that could resemble the disaster Nokia had with the Booklet 3G. To cut the Booklet 3G story short, let's just say that at the end of the day, Nokia has only shown leadership and expertise in designing, manufacturing and selling mobile devices, not computers.

Windows RT also faces its own problems, that Microsoft hasn't been able to fix, barely even address. People don't really know what WindowsRT is for, and so people haven't but a choice to think its full Windows on a tablet. This couldn't be farther from the truth. It's a completely new tablet platform that only borrows branding and design elements from its half-sister Windows 8. The misconception around what WinRT is has spawned some gloomy scenarios for the platform at the fingers of bloggers, but the truth remains that nobody is quite sure what to think about WinRT tablets.


Tapping into Nokia’s strengths 

Nokia's strengths at the moment lie in design, quality hardware and innovative technologies and premium exclusive software on their Lumia phones.  In addition to this Nokia tends to bring unsurpassed price to quality ratio to their devices.

In practice this means state of the art imaging technology, world class location services and a huge variety of apps wrapped in gorgeous but affordable packages. These are all strengths that must make it onto Nokia's tablet. This isn't enough, though if you ask me. Following the mentioned recipe in a tablet will only result in a Lumia-looking tablet. For the user it feels like a huge Lumia phone, just possibly without telephony functions.

I'm certain Nokia has had some elaborate plans for the form factor, such as wrap-cover keyboards etc., but with the launch of Surface I think a slew of those ideas might've gone to the bin. This is the most fuzzy part of the Nokia tablet for me though I must admit, as for the life of me I can't imagine what Nokia will come up with on this front. I bet a lot of people over at Nokia sighed a "geez thanks" at the Surface launch event!

The answer lies in... specialization! 

So here's my horse I'm going to be betting on: an array of tablets designed at doing only a few things (not everything), but doing them well.

One example of this might be a music centric tablet, that has great built-in speakers and connectivity to media devices you might already have in your house. It would have a premium and a little-sister version with a more compact form factor and cheaper price.

The second type of tablet could be one aimed at business use. It would come with an accessory of an attachable keyboard and perhaps a wireless option too. It would have a high-quality webcam for conference Skype calls in mind, and probably a kick-stand type solution to help positioning for its use case scenario.

All tablets would naturally benefit from Nokia's deep and wide ecosystem of accessories.


Conclusions

These two examples aren't imperatives to Nokia or ready product concepts, but I hope they present the core of my idea. Having the tablets concentrate on a clear function will make it easier to market, and will make it harder to get misconceptions about. Marketing can concentrate on touting what the device does well, instead of thinking of a way to talk about what it can't do. Specialisation is an idea that hasn't been ventured into yet, at least not fully so this could be a way to enter the market with something fresh.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Imagining the Nokia tablet

Mobile World Congress 2013 has come and gone, and we didn't see a Nokia tablet. I set upon imagining the Nokia tablet and what it would in reality be, and I got the feeling that seeing a tablet from Nokia is still a long way away. In this post I evaluate some of the difficulties Nokia faces in releasing a tablet and speculate features, forms and technological wow-factors it could come to encompass. At the same time, I ponder how Microsoft's Surface effort, as well as mismanaging Windows RT and Windows 8 might've messed with Nokia's tablet plans.

My impressions of the current situation on the market
Having a tablet to compete in the ever converging mobile space seems to be a must in the Western world. Not every consumer has a tablet, but just about everyone is starting to have a smart phone. At the same time people are moving away from traditional (desktop) PCs and ultra portables are becoming more popular. I understand this is the emerging market often titled as the "post PC market" that manufacturers are racing to capture.

At the moment the tablet market is dominated by two players: Apple with their iPads and Samsung with their army of Android powered Galaxy Tab devices. A lot of other manufacturers offer tablets, but only these two manufacturers have managed to sell tablets in the (tens of) millions. Apple's and Samsung's success can be explained by, well, having a tablet in the first place to sell, but also being first ones to offer a truly consumer-friendly tablet experience. Apple's "one-size-fits-all" approach with just one model a year is met by Samsung's "one-of-these-sizes-must-fit-someone" approach, which in practice means a plethora of Galaxy Tab branded tablets in all thicknesses and screen sizes and in just about all price points.

What then can be Nokia's angle with which to conquer the tablet market?

Operating systems
The operating system aboard Nokia's tablet will most certainly be one designed by Microsoft. As much as I'd love to fantasise MeeGo-Harmattan based tablets, in all honesty I think Microsoft's platform is the only viable platform (that is in existence and ready) that can handle tablet-device duties and is available to Nokia.

Rumours also have it that Nokia will be launching a Windows RT powered tablet. Some hoped it would happen at MWC13. Then we learned that Nokia had only done some prototypes that mostly tried out different form-factors for tablets, and that nothing had survived the process to become a final consumer product. Yet. I feel that if there's some debate over Nokia tablet's operating system, it revolves more around the question will it be Windows RT, or full on Windows 8.

Windows RT is a "simplified" Windows 8, with support only for apps that make use of the 'Modern UI'. Basically  it looks like the Windows 8 app launcher that you can see when you press the Windows button in Win8. Biggest caveats in WinRT by public opinion seem to be: no desktop, heavy reliance on developers making 'Modern UI' versions of apps, and apps can only be downloaded from the Microsoft store. Right now the Microsoft store is pretty empty. I think Windows RT's real problems don't rely in the mentioned limitations, but that Microsoft's marketing hasn't been able to differentiate it significantly enough from Windows 8. People seem to regard it as a version of Windows 8, that's found on tablets. That's why they are dissapointed, when you don't have the full-power of the Windows desktop product, in a product that uses the Windows branding. Proof of the existence of this "Windows illusion" is in the fact that nobody for a second stops to criticize that Google based tablets only allow downloading from the Google Play store and iPads can only download apps from the AppStore. To me this is proof that people quite haven't wrapped their head around what Windows RT really is. A lot of this misconception is Microsoft's own fault though as they made some empty promises and gave out some misleading information relating to the operating system's capabilities.

Microsoft has failed in marketing it as a "streamlined tablet OS utilising functions from the Windows products" and instead its viewed as a "Windows 8, compromise edition. Half the features and half the functions you expect. And no legacy apps!". These misconceptions have made Windows RT an operating system with a frankly negative reputation, making the job for Nokia ever harder. Samsung is cancelling Windows RT tablet-PC hybrids in the US and countries of the EU because of low demand. It's becoming ever harder to see how Nokia's WinRT effort could turn this around.

I see some technical reasons why Nokia would be interested in using Microsoft's Windows RT on their tablet instead of the full-fledged Windows 8, though. Unlike Samsung and Apple, Nokia has little to no experience in the PC market. Nokia's Booklet 3G was a lick away from a disaster, so I bet Nokia is much more careful to not get burned again in a market unfamiliar to them. Should Nokia chose Windows RT, it would place Nokia's products closer to the expertise Nokia already has. Windows RT devices run on hardware very similar to those on smart phones and so Nokia could utilise existing partnerships. After-sales support is a lot more manageable when you can utilise your current support (or Nokia Care) chain you already have in place. In the times of the Booklet 3G, smart phones and computers were worlds apart in design and manufacturing costs. Marketing a tablet these days is similar to marketing a smart phone, especially if you can make the connection between the operating systems running on both devices. Booklet 3G's Windows XP was worlds apart from Symbian, and there was no real coherence between Nokia's smartphone products and the Booklet. Running full-fledged Windows 8 would again create a gap between Nokia's handset products and its tablet products. Naturally, also hardware requirements would be very different.

Physical form factor and hardware
Right now Nokia is having a great run in their physical designs of their products. Design award after design award has been won ever since the N9/Lumia 800 form factor and now Nokia's influence on design can (in my opinion) be seen also in other manufacturers' products. Suddenly we're getting devices and accessories with vibrant and brave colours, and not just those black, steel-gray or white devices. I trust no other company as much as I do Nokia in coming up with a truly unique tablet design. Just how they will do this is still unlcear for me, but I think the Nokia tablet that will end up being released won't be a ~10inch slab of glass and plastic.

Nokia could simply make a tablet that looks like a Lumia phone. I just don't think that this would be enough for the current Nokia. Microsoft's Surface tablet addressed this issue of generic tablet design by introducing a kick-stand to the device, colourful removable keyboards/protective shields and a MicroSD slot. If Nokia had been first to design a tablet with these functions, I feel Nokia could've A) brought some extra Nokia-wow to these features and B) marketed it much better. I also believe that Nokia would've looked more into actual user cases for the device, making its physical feel a lot better than the Surface. (By no means is the Surface a failed effort, however in my opinion.) Now that Microsoft has cleared the table with the Surface, I guess a lot of Nokia's ideas might've been sent back to zero. There's something about the form factors of the Surface tablet so Nokian that I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if it turned out that Nokia designed the Surface. So I find myself thinking, what else is very Nokian right now in Nokia's products?

Nokia's state-of-the-art imaging technology is what wowed us in the Lumia 920 and Lumia 720, and design is what wowed us with the Lumia 620, Lumia 520 and for me personally the Lumia 820. Other Nokia's strengths at this time are their location based services and their wide array of Lumia-exclusive apps. These features don't seem to me as selling-points for a tablet, though. I feel that for the tablet, Nokia must come up with a new technology or some new innovation, or else Nokia's tablet will just seem like a big Lumia phone.

Specialisation
One possibly less adventured development path would be the road of specialisation. By specialisation I mean that Nokia would design their tablet to do fewer things, but to do them well. A music-oriented device would be particularly interesting to me, and it would continue nicely Nokia's concentration with music. Nokia already has a Windows 8 version of their app Nokia Music, which could be the center-piece in their music-oriented tablet. The tablet would naturally have NFC to connect to the array of NFC enabled music accessories from Nokia (and JBL). The speakers on the device it self could also be top-class, but by this I don't mean big. Current ultrabooks such as my Zenbook has tiny speakers designed by Bang & Olufsen, that sound a lot better than traditional laptop speakers. The device would pack a lot of internal memory and be upgradeable with MicroSD cards for people to load with MP3s and video files. Bluetooth 3.0 or a similar technology would ensure that file transfer could happen also without wires. Spotify would be a good launch partner and would erase the bad memory of Spotify's lackluster support for Windows Phone. I believe a Spotify app is in the works for Windows RT. Physical design of this device could have "play/pause, next and previous track" buttons. Physically it could be a smaller 7" tablet, with the adolescent audience and women in mind. (Many probably don't know this, but even the N9 was originally designed to please the female audience. Turns out everyone loved it, so this could be a killer recipe.)

Another specialised tablet could be one designed for corporate use. It would have a webcam of great quality, and a great set of microphones for Skype calling. It would come with a deattachable keyboard of course, and Windows already has support for just about all Bluetooth keyboards out there. At launch Nokia would introduce a few of its own keyboards of course. The tablet would have wireless charging technology to make keeping all of your devices, including the tablet itself, running on full battery. The deattachable keyboard would bring extra battery life to the product and serve as a wireless charger. Microsoft's cloud-based Office solutions would play a key role here and be heavily present in the marketing. This tablet would also be every bloggers dream bit of kit to take to live-blogging events. Nokia would introduce at launch a few new auxiliary power solutions tailored for this device, but usable by other Nokia products as well.

Specialisation like this could be a way around the problem with Windows RT at the moment. Marketing Nokia's device as a strictly specialised product could take away from the illusion that Windows RT should be able to do everything Windows 8 does. It wouldn't even attempt to compete with "full" Windows 8 devices. Specialisation could also be the way to bring added value to people that have tablets now. I feel that Android and iOS based tablets offer only "more of the same" you've come to expect on those platforms in smartphones. Sure some apps make use of the larger screen, but in all honesty you're doing the same things on a tablet you're doing on your phone. This has been reason enough for me to conclude that I don't need a tablet. Specialisation could be a fresh new way out of the stagnated slate-inflated tablet market. It would also give a nice excuse to sell multiple devices of different purpoes to the same customer.

Conclusion
Nokia has some real strengths right now, making them the most viable Windows Phone manufacturer today. The Nokia tablet should have features we already enjoy about Nokia's current product portfolio: it should contain a wide array of Nokia apps we enjoy on the Lumias, it should make use of Nokia's location services and perhaps their imaging technology too. The tablet is a product that requires something new from Nokia however. It would need a new technology or a new innovation, but it should bring something new to the table in terms of how we use tablets. This is by no means a small feat and even with my idea of specialisation I don't think the picture is quite ready for a viable Nokia tablet. It's not only up to Nokia either. Microsoft have to do some extensive face saving with the reputation and perceptions around Windows RT.

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Why (not) Windows Phone 8?


Last article on this site was about my reasons for sticking with Windows Phone 7 over everything else out there. In this article I try to explain why, contrary to my enthusiast nature, I'm thinking of not changing from Windows Phone 7 even to Windows Phone 8.

Towards the end of October '12, we finally saw the wraps come off some notable Windows Phone 8 devices. Samsung opened the game with ATIV S, shortly followed by Nokia and HTC. All of these devices offered a lot of specs to drool over, but I can't help to think that for me the operating system it self is the least exciting thing about these new devices.

Let's compare the situation to the Android and even iOS world. Every time there's new devices announced, they also make a very big deal over how the OS has evolved in its latest iteration. Android manufacturers and Apple upgrade their operating system, but offer higher specs in the devices as well. Sure, this isn't a guaranteed way to make money (such as HTC's beautiful and powerful One-lineup proved), but it becomes pretty clear to consumers as to why make the jump.

The most awaited feature in Windows Phone 8 for me is ... drumroll .... the new theme colours. Yeah, not Kid's corner, not that Room thing, not the resizeable live tiles, not the support for new technical feature a-z, but the theme or accent colours. Sure, Microsoft is very lucky that they've enrolled a device manufacturer that has been willing to pour its heart out in innovation into their WP8 device, increasing drooling potential significantly. Still I feel this isn't a merit of the platform itself at all, and I pack the 808 for when I need a mobile camera. Other features I love about WP7 remain unchanged in WP8, so why do the upgrade?

Yeah, so?

So, sales and especially pre-order sales have been great for some Windows Phone 8 devices, so I must be in the minority who think that WP8 isn't anything too great. Right? Well, I think there's more to this here. Let's explore a little farther.

Windows Phone 7.8, the update to all current Windows Phone 7.5 devices. Rumours spread around the web a couple of weeks ago, that on the 28th of November, WP7.8 would be released to the masses. Wednesday rolled around, and all we got was a Microsoft statement that they've pushed it back to Q1 2013. Whenever a date pops into the rumour-o-sphere that is Twitter, we can usually be pretty sure that the software is ready or just about ready to be released.

There can then be only market-strategic reasons for not releasing the software. I think that the reason this time is, that they don't want to risk sales of Windows Phone 8, and will go far and wide to take precautions. If I, for example, would have been given WP7.8 on the 28th, I don't think I would even be writing this blog post. Windows Phone 8 would feel so irrelevant to me. I'd have all I wanted:  my precious theme colours. There was a lot of commotion when WP7.8 was announced, as people were expecting a free update to WP8. Since that day I've felt though, that because WP7.8 and WP8 will look the same, the real differences between the operating systems will soon be forgotten. I think Microsoft is aware of this as well, and this is the reason they're pushing it back.

High demand and interest for WP8 comes from people, who aren't on the platform yet, but refused to do the jump 6-8 months back when it was "killed" WP7 months after it got popular and got its first flagship devices.

Conclusions: my suggestion to Microsoft

Now that you've bought yourself some time with WP7.8, make it mandatory that in the installation phase you will be greeted with a checklist comparing WP7.8 to WP8. I think we satisfied, current customers should be reminded why we're only applying the "WP8 skin" to our system. You could remind us of the strict hardware restrictions that have made "real" new features a near impossibility on older devices. Trash talking your own product like this probably isn't the way to go, but maybe you get my drift.

Sales for Windows Phone 7 devices were rubbish, but there's still a couple of million of us out here, so make the effort of selling Windows Phone 8 to us.

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Why have I stuck with Windows Phone?




A lot of people ask me what it is that I like about Windows Phone, or worse, they ask me "if its good". I have a hard time answering, as I know they don't have the patience for me to tell them all my reasons why I like it or why I've stuck with it since early 2012. I feel my blog is a more fitting forum for my explanation, so here it is. Enjoy!

Look and feel

In the very beginning it was the fascination of a new thing, but the fluidity and classiness of the whole user experience and the differentiated look intrigued me from day one. My first WP7 device was the HTC Trophy 7, as I imagine it was for a lot of people too. I wasn't too impressed by the operating system at its version then, but HTC's hardware design downright turned me off. Windows Phone seemed to suffer from a number of problems that I've never encountered since then.  Problems included stupefyingly low battery life, and the chance that the entire device might freeze during a phone call. I suspect these were problems with the hardware, though. Battery life is still a worry with the Lumia 800 that I'm using, but at least I get the standard ~6 hrs I need before absolutely having to charge the device. My Lumia 800 has never completely jammed, none of the core apps have ever crashed on me and there's just been no show-stopping problems ever.

As mentioned, the thing that has really pulled me in is the look, sound and feel of the platform. Somehow I felt right at home with WP7 after the N9. Using a WP7 device is an audal and visual pleasure, although no device has managed to top the haptic feedback you get from typing with the N9. Microsoft's approach was to insert a cute tapping sound to the keyboard which is really nice, but obtainable by anyone really. It takes a company with experience to pay attention to such details, as to what your vibramotor on the circuit board of your device feels like to the user when it goes off. Typing on the N9 almost feels like typing on a semi-physical keyboard. I hope to see this in Nokia's future WP devices.

Apps, or the lack of thereof

As a lover of the N900, I always felt sort of envious over the mapping support on Symbian. Maps on Maemo5 were like an early alpha build of Maps compared to what was on Symbian. This applied to a lot of apps available on the big brother platform. Everything Nokia supported on the N900 felt like it was under development, until it (very quickly) became abandoned. You had lots of enthusiastic coders and hackers, but nothing was ever consumer ready, and you couldn't really rely on any app to work when you really needed it. Switching to a Symbian phone wasn't an option either, because, well, Symbian. Let's not have that discussion here. You can read about my thoughts on S^3 here. The same feeling of apps being incomplete or not intended for serious use crept in every now and then on the N9 as well, although I must applaud companies that had full-heartedly placed their trust in the MeeGo-Harmattan platform and created fully functional, premium feeling apps for it. My biggest problem was always Nokia's own lack of effort towards the core social media apps and the simply lackluster browser. In Windows Phone (Mango) the browser is top class, it even gets around the Flash issue no problem by great media player integration as soon as a HTML5 website is spotted. Some people complain that the social media aspect of the built-in apps is lackluster, and that they end up installing a Twitter and Facebook client anyway. For me, Twitter works just fine and I'm not a big fan of Facebook. Thanks to Windows Phone's integrated Facebook features, though, I've never before been so up to date with my friends new pictures. For me pictures are the most fun part about Facebook! I've also noticed I spend more time looking at people's profiles when I want to re-establish contact with them. Feels suitable to do that when I'm on my phone.

Adopting a new mobile OS paradigm

Like mentioned, people complain that core apps are lacking in WP, but they're also the reason why it felt like a breath of fresh air after clutter-madness Android. Sure in the beginning I missed having all the apps I wanted on the device and sure I missed having alternatives for the Calendar app, for example. Windows Phone first appeared to me as incomplete. However, once I was forced out of this mindset, it felt quite pleasing that I was forced into working with only a few tools. This way calendar entries or settings were never lost when installing another app, and setting up the phone only takes 1 hour after a reflash. I can concentrate on things more important to me than adjusting my default e-mail, browser, and photo application “to be used when performing this action”. I always detested the “there’s an app for that” mentality that came with the iPhone. I want everything built-in, running smooth, always there. My #1 used feature on my Windows Phone device is the in-built instant messaging services. When I use the IM service, I feel like I’m back on my N900 again as SMS and IM are all integrated in the same app. I mean really, why should they be differentiated into separate apps?

Conclusions

So here are my thoughts on Windows Phone 7 as we currently know it. Windows Phone 8 will certainly be a huge improvement, although personally I won’t be too sad to be stuck with WP7.8 on my Lumia 800. There’s really nothing I really need from Windows Phone 8, but of course I will be looking into getting the Lumia 920 or the HTC 8X. Another thing going for Windows Phone is how it seems to be forcing manufacturers to come up with colourful and different designs. This could be just Nokia’s influence on the mobile space, but in the end it means that we’ve broken past trying to out iPhone the iPhone. Wonderful times ahead!


Sunday, September 2, 2012

"Three-star Samsung", discussion over article in Helsingin Sanomat 2.9.12.


Helsingin Sanomat wrote a story titled "Kolmen tähden Samsung" or "Three-star Samsung" (my freestyle translation), where the new mobile industry giant is probed and dissected, providing a lot of surprising and interesting information from a former insider, Sami Paihonen.

This is my freeform translation of that article, as this post will also attempt to discuss the contents of the article. Therefore it won't be a 1:1 translation, and I will be cherry-picking topics of interest out of it. Hope you enjoy this as much as I enjoyed writing it. Full credits of the article can be found at the end of the story.

UPDATE: James Song from Samsung admits to Samsung looking like "copycat". LINK

In Finland much of the media covering the mobile space is dominated by Nokia news. To date I must've read a hundred stories on Nokia's fall, the latest one just this week. As informative and accurate as these stories are, they don't convey the full picture of what's going on in the battle between the giants over dominance over the smartphones game. There is much more to the situation than simply winning or losing, as no company is perfect. Also, I think that to most Finns, Nokia's greatest rival is still Apple and iOS, where as in reality the more formidable opponent, the one Nokia has to beat to rise to its former glory, has for very long been Samsung.

Helsingin Sanomat is the first magazine to write an in-depth article on Samsung, and leave Nokia only to the margins. Naturally this new interest in Samsung was flared after news of Apple gained a significant win over Samsung in US court. Its surprising how unknown Samsung is in Finland given the realities of the situation. The article is aware of this and is quick to point out, that we might know Steve Jobs, but do we know who Lee Kun-Hee is?

The article starts off by delving into the lawsuit, and Sami Paihonen is quick to point out, that the verdict of the jury wasn't a big surprise to him. Imitation is deep in the Korean corporate culture, where the strategy seems to be to imitate the competition, grow like this until you're as big as them, and then top them in their own game. Samsung is a prime example of following this principle according to the article. If imitation is a prime modus operandi, what happens to innovation?

Paihonen says, that during his employment in Samsung's designcentre 2008-2010, he tried to bring innovation to the table, but found his efforts constantly turned down "upstairs". As an example he mentions a project where his team developed a way to zoom into content, such as pictures and webpages, using only one finger. To me, this sounds like a better way to do it, as many appreciate it if they can use their mobiles using only one hand. The team's idea was, however turned down and Samsung decided to go with "pinch to zoom" which we all know originates from Apple products.

Nokia's strengths have previously been, that they could efficiently produce phones on their own plants under tight control and little dependency. Samsung shares this strength, as the Korean giant manufactures a lot of home appliances to cruise ships and skyscrapers. Even Apple is totally dependent on Samsung's deliveries, despite of the feuds in court. This combined with Samsung's work culture, ie. the longest days and hardest execs to whip the most out of their employees makes Samsung an object of adoration in its homeland. Samsung doesn't have a workers union, which speaks volumes of the company's inner workings if you ask me.

To wrap it all together, Helsingin Sanomat quotes Finnish consultant Christian Lindholm saying, that Samsung's a great soap salesman. The product gets the job done and sells in volumes, but lacks the attractability of premium perfumes that have the consumer going gaga over, and paying top dollar for. Although Samsung's Galaxy S lineup has been immensely successful, they still don't have a succulent premium product that everyone wants a piece of, such as Apple has its iPhone. I came to this conclusion as well in my Galaxy S2 review.

To contrast what the article is saying into recent news from the mobile space, the Ativ S from Samsung has gathered a decent amount of attention, but shone a somewhat negative light on its elder brother, the Samsung Galaxy S3. Bloggers have deemed the Galaxy S3 as a rather plain looking phone compared to the Ativ S, the giant's first smartphone running Windows Phone 8. People criticizing the way Samsung's top-end phones look was largely unheard of until this time. With Nokia's announcements in their Lumia line-up might place even more pressure on Samsung to deliver good looking devices, as Nokia's WP7 phones are renowned for their physical appeal. So in this sense, I think we've very recently been served many a good example of Samsung's devices lack physical attractiveness and uniqueness.


Original article by Helsingin Sanomat
Written by Anssi Miettinen
Published 2.9.2012.
Those with access to HS Verkkolehti, direct link to article here.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Jolla promises to fight low app count with "interesting solution"

This article is based on Finnish magazine IT-Viikko's article on the newly announced Jolla Mobile startup. This article is a "translation" out of request by Tomi Ahonen.





Jolla Mobile is every MeeGo and mobile Linux enthusiast's new best friend, and probably the most interesting startup from Finland in mid-2012. Jolla Mobile promises to "continue" Nokia's MeeGo work with MeeGo powered devices of their own. 

One of the problems facing the start-up is answering the competition over apps. Modern day smartphone platforms thrive on the apps they run, and the competition (Android, iOS, and even Symbian) have appstores filled to the brimm with apps. It is still uncertain, if apps made for Nokia's N9 device can be run on the to-be-announced range of MeeGo devices from Jolla.

According to Finnish magazine IT-Viikko, CEO of Jolla Mobile Jussi Hurmola promises that Jolla has "an interesting answer" to the challenge.
' It is evident that we must face up to this challenge. Our solution is so interesting, though that it is better left for revealing at the same time with our announcements.' Hurmola says cryptically. The CEO is reluctant to address confusion over whether apps from the MeeGo-Harmattan device N9 will work on Jolla's devices.

To add to the secrecy, Hurmola adds that 'we have contemplated a total separation from so called smartphones, although our first product will be a phone.' Jolla Mobile's first device will arrive before year's end. 'New device categories pop up all the time, and they change every year.' he says. 'It will be interesting to see, what kinds of new device categories will emerge.'

Jolla has "open and close" relations to Nokia says Hurmola. Nokia gave Jolla Mobile a share of patents that relate to MeeGo. (This turns out to be incorrect, also IT-Viikko corrected themselves! Thanks for the tip!) Jolla has participated in Nokia's Bridge-programme, where Jolla's business plan was reviewed and accepted by Nokia. Nokia's Bridge-programme attempts to ease the formation of startups of former Nokia employees.

Friday, April 6, 2012

We the pioneers of the touchscreen age: How will our time be remember?




We live in a special time, as our time will be the time remembered as the era when touchscreens became the norm. Touchscreen enabled devices became a commercial success fundamentally changing how we used our devices and what we did on them. The touchscreen is being introduced alongside a host of new technologies, promising an excitement filled future in personal electronis. How exactly will we remember these 'early times' however? Here are my tongue-in-cheek thoughts on the subject.


UPDATE: Here's a link by AAWP titled "Has Apple put mobile innovation back 10 years?" Link -- enjoy!


Operating systems that go boing, blonk, blink in the night




With added intelligence to our devices, they started feeding us a lot of information. Who's online, how's the battery status, what's the weather etc., these were all things we suddenly wanted to know. Our devices began to feed this information to us in a way we humans sometimes force feed our unwilling children. There isn't a single operating system on a mobile device today that doesn't use an intricate notification system consisting of sounds and lights to let us know exactly what is going on. Simply adjusting the volume on some devices produces a monotone sonata of sounds to let you know that 'Hey, you've just adjusted the volume. Good for you, buddy'. Textual pop-ups or 'Toasts' write it out for anyone still unsure of what is going on. After the event, notifications of the event linger all around "status bars" and "notification centres" just in case you missed it.


What's the time, how's the weather, what's the time?




Relating to the information overload we now expected from our devices, it became fashionable to have you reminded of the weather and time 100% of the time you use your device. Desktops and Home screens filled with clock and weather widgets, and user interfaces revolved around elaborate symbolic systems to constantly keep you updated on exactly how the weather and time is. We took being informed about the time and weather to such an extent, that some manufacturers' devices shipped with up to 10 different clocks to place on home screens. In addition to this, we filled our appstores with hundreds more such applications. This keen fascination on the time and weather resulted in a pathological popping down of heads to check our phones, at least twice because we were distracted by the weather widget and forgot to actually see the time. We have never been so informed about what time it is or what we should expect when we step out in to the real world, that you'd think tardiness and dressing too lightly for cold days were mankinds problems solved for good. I think its safe to say, that statistics of every boss everywhere indicate otherwise.




Smaller is better and biggest is best




With the touchscreen becoming the new norm, people began to receive larger devices. Increased screen real estate meant watching video and browsing the web never felt so good. Big bright screens became the ideal, and it wasn't until the reached the 4" mark that got the feeling that we'd had enough. Of course by the time we got here, enter the iPad and tablet computers.




The big screens challenged engineers to come up with ever slimmer devices, as devices were expected to grow in terms of display size, but nobody wanted a chubby buddy in their pocket. Few problems were introduced here, though as huge screens were getting bent in trouser pockets and once a touchscreen broke, the lifeline of the device had practically ended. Warranty policies of manufacturers didn't choose to cover touchpanels shattered after falling from speeding bikes onto the pavement or phones misplaced in blenders. Coincidentally, the warranty policy of the most popular mobile devices decreased from the standard of two years into one year.




The neverending dressup game




As we began to sport this fragile and expensive gear in our pockets, we tried to calm our nerves about the worst-case-scenarios running through our minds. Our outlet was the buying of accessories in attempts to protect our device from its inevitable fate. We bought it silicone covers, hard plastic covers, see-through plastic film to place over the touch panel and placed our device inside a protective bag of some sort. Just in case we paid attention to placing the device in our pocket with the display against our thigh! Never before had manufacturers seen customers invest this much money in products that could be produced from the waste material every manufacturer is going to have anyway. People were willing to pay roughly 10 times the material's worth to buy a product to protect a device with an already remarkable profit margin.


"Third party" manufacturers weren't the only ones to latch on to this trend however, as a notable manufacturers of mobile devices began offering different coloured battery covers with their devices. Smartphone users were partying with changeable covers like it was 1998 again, with the Nokia 5110 and its 'Xpress On Covers'. How advanced our needs had become!




One handed two handers / silence of the lambs




Touch-only devices introduced some limitations in use also, namely hindering getting anything productive done on the device at all. Virtual keyboards were slower and more cumbersome to type on, so many text messages were simply left unsent, I imagine. Or then reduced to platonic confirmations such as "OK", "YES" or "GTFO". Internet browsing was a big part of the smartphone experience, but people who were used to being actively involved in social media were now forced to the spectator seat. No telling in detail what's going on, a simple "Go dolphnns!1!!q" with a check-in to Facebook would have to suffice.


A somewhat ironic debate spurred around the touch user interfaces relating on these devices as well. Some felt that the only good UI is one that you can use one-handed. Some products were put down for requiring two-handed use (such as any device with a physical QWERTY keyboard), but in reality all typing on most touch-screen devices had to be done using two hands by holding the device sideways or in "landscape" position. As no virtual keyboard ever could fully replace a physical one, for a time Westeners fell into a forced silence as suddenly replying to messages was more cumbersome than waiting to get to a place where they could just call back later.


Efforts to alleviate difficulties caused by virtual keyboards did produce some entertaining technologies and subsequently websites, damnyouautocorrect.com being in the forefront in entertainment value.


It's not what you've got, It's what you might get




As smartphone software became more advanced, and competition to get your smartphone device out on the market became tougher, update total overhaul cycles for mobile operating systems were introduced. Manufacturers released half-baked operating systems with limited functionality and were praised for customer loyalty for including features we actually had already had in our phones pre-touch.


Waiting for the next software update became a game as well, as people planned their device purchases on abstract notions over possibilities of updates for their devices. Needless to say, if a manufacturer deemed one of its products as unupgradable, the outrage was incomprehensible - regardless of weather users were satisfied with their device at the moment or not. It became the right of the common man to demand features and functions to his device that were appearing in new models, sometimes even over two years after the purchase of the current one. The need to break restrictions set by the manufacturer created phenomena now commonly referred to as 'gaining root' or 'rooting' and 'jailbreaking'. Once these restrictions were circumvented, users could enjoy community provided enhancements and features to their device, often with the cost of voiding the warranty.


This created some real problems for device manufacturers, as suddenly their newest product lineup had lost its edge in terms of new features and functions, just months after release. Interestingly this produced two reactions: some made it deliberately even easier to circumvent their devices in hopes of hacker appreciation, some decided to tighten the restrictions and many decided to strive for a completely customisable experience known as an Open Source platform.


Ironically, the systems that included all features and functions ever invented for mobile phones lost their fame because of the way in which they handed these features to consumers. Users reported bad experiences with "ugly boxes" and "nonexistent graphical transition effects". The solution for this was to switch to an operating system equally as raw as a green mango.


One device to do it all, just without the tools




Once we were all under the impression that the entire software platform of our device was constantly developing from its already developed state, we started forgetting about our productive capability on our devices. All computers and even mobile phones we had used up until the touch-screen era had supported the running of many applications at once (for example MS Paint and the Calculator, or the music player and text messages), but in the early touch-era we let go of all that. This kind of application use is called multitasking, by the way. As if being hindered by the slowness of virtual keyboards wasn't enough, we didn't mind starting the writing of our e-mail from the beginning if a notification threw us into the alarm clock application, forcing the e-mail application to restart and forgetting all we had typed before. We no longer minded the fact that we'd been stopped from doing what we were doing, and simply decided to 'call back later'.


There was a time when we were used to functional applications or tools on our devices, that could help us in the daily tasks we face. Many smartphones were marketed as being a 'mobile office' with their range of functional manufacturer provided apps, although often displaying anything more complex than a mobile version of a website proved impossible. We however bought into this willingly, and even went about boasting about what our devices could do. Surely there was someone out there who had even worse productivity than us, right?


Upsides to the story


As some might've noticed, this piece has been deeply sarcastic and I hope it hasn't turned off any of you. I do admit, that there are upsides to larger screens and trends relating to them and I'm in no way trying to discredit that. Also, for example perhaps the first time in personal device history, it has been fashionable to be easy to use and manufacturers have figured out ways to actually make devices easy to use. To me this is unprecedented in the history of electronics.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Samsung Galaxy S II: Maybe the Best Android phone in World?


Phones seem to be raining in my lap lately, and this time I caught one in a nice slim form factor. Even its very plasticy all around, its Super AMOLED+ screen fails to leave me wanting more. The Samsung Galaxy S II seems to be aimed at the enthusiasts, while catoring some mass-market dumb-downs in terms of software. Overall I feel it lacks to premium feel a product of this price should have.

Samsung's Galaxy S I sold very well pretty much everywhere it was sold and perhaps launched Samsung into the top three smartphone manufacturers. It certainly crowned Samsung as the biggest Android manufacturer. Samsung is also slowly taking on an innovator's role in innovating new mobile technology. Samsung already marks the manufacturer with the best quality displays in their devices.


Weightless impressions

Samsung's legacy as a manufacturer with the greatest screens holds true when considering the Samsung Galaxy S II. It is equipped with a super AMOLED screen with a little "+" added to the name. I'm sure a Google search can tell you how AMOLED+ differs from just AMOLED, but I can tell you it looks good.

The Galaxy S II is incredibly thin and it sports a huge 4.3" screen. Otherwise this device would feel huge due to its screen, but its thinness of just about 0.9 cm really makes it dissappear into your pocket. At least it did in mine. The thinness is accompanied by an incredible weightlessness, which adds to the potential to losing this device in your pocket. This I believe is a good thing!

The thinness and lightness is probably what most enthusiasts are looking for in a "latest and greatest" smartphone, and here Sammy's GSII scores a perfect A I imagine. However, for me these factors diminshed how precious the device felt. With weight I associate value, and with the SGSII weighing this little, my impression is flimsy at best.

Mesmerised by the AMOle... woooooow
The huge Super AMOLED+ screen gave the device an initial impression of a mini-tablet of some sort. Gazing over it with a slight dribble of drool down the left side of my face I imagined all the things that would fit on the screen. I'm familiar with the DesireZ, where the screen is "only" 3.7" running at a resolution of 480x800. To much of my surprise, the GSII runs at the exact same resolution. With the added screen real-estate this resolution renders much of the operating system a bit funny looking. Huge fonts are found here and there and many colour gradients lose their effect. Samsung's custom UI utilises simplified boxes and fonts, maximizing approachability and clarity. At the same time it makes the interface quite ugly and oversimplified at times. Another oddity was the somewhat random automatic adjustment of the screen brightness.


Software and design

Note: my Sammy GS2 ran Gingerbread. Not unusual to Android, Samsung's device comes preloaded with a lot of bloatware. Especially bloated are the homescreens on first startup. 5 screens are filled to the brim with Samsung's widgets and shortcuts. Expect to spend the first 10mins of using this device just getting rid of everything. Another common thing to the Android experience is the constant overlapping of services and creation of new accounts for ambiguous benefits. I for one signed up for a "Samsung account" when prompted, but failed to find any place in the system where I could benefit from this. I suspect it demanded the creation to check for system updates. How rude.

Learning Android really requires you to understand which apps are part of core Android and which apps are just core apps customised by the manufacturer for hopes of bringing extra value to the device. This might lead to you enabling your Facebook account and contacts for the core Facebook app, your manufacturers Facebook app and a third app you got from the Market. Care to guess how many contact duplicates this creates in your addressbook? This combined with multiple notifications of the same event from many different programs can result in chaos. This issue is a general rant about Android, though, and is in no way only the SGSII's problem.

Not all customisations made by manufacturers are for the worse, however. For example I've always been a fan of Samsung's take on e-mail and the calendar. The e-mail app replaced my need for K9-mail all together. Well done, Sammy! I imagine business users might feel at home here thanks to not only Sammy's apps, but also thanks to the endless supply of apps available from the Android Market. Security might be another thing all together, though.


Creativity

The Galaxy S II's huge screen makes typing on the landscape virtual keyboard almost as efficient as on a physical one. The portrait QWERTY also does the trick. I'm using the Samsung virtual keyboard. My positive experiences with the keyboard begged the question if this device for any good for creativity.

The Galaxy S II comes preinstalled with a full version of Polaris Office. Stylish and functional this program seems to cater to most desires you might have for mobile document creation. Sadly the virtualkeyboard in Android always ends up blocking over half of the screen making it hard to see what you type as well as hiding toolbars of Polar Office. Sigh. Thought I left all this behind when I switched over from Nokia's 5800XM in 2009.

Another odd snigglet on the SGII is the browser. For me the measure of a good smartphone is its browser, so you can imagine my amazement when I found out that the browser only supports mobile pages by default. I read around the web about this issue, and it seems that some versions of the SGSII comes with the option of setting the default view to 'Desktop'. In my SGSII this was nowhere to be found and I had to do a "about:useragent" in the address bar instead. Sadly the browser doesn't want to remember this setting, forcing me to get Dolphin Browser HD. To me this was a slap in the face for a device in this price range.


Conclusions

My understanding of the SGSII was that it was the absolute wet dream of the Android enthusiast, but I think it doesn't really answer that call to the fullest, except perhaps for its slimness and screen size. The physical design and look of the device is somehow deeply old-school of Samsung. I think they manufactured devices that looked like this about 5 yrs. ago. This didn't appeal to me at all and the SGSII is more an ugly slab to me than a premium product or flagship device. The processor power, display and memory might be impressive, but I can't really see it used in the system. Samsung's UI seems more fitting to a phone in a lower price point as it uses straight-forward fonts with no stylizing and no cream. It's really devoid of premium feel, but packed with functionality. Therefore this isn't only a criticism. The weightlessness and plastic feel don't make this device a bad phone, but just one not of this price range I feel.



Thursday, February 9, 2012

Nokia Lumia 800: the first few days

The Lumia 800, the Windows Phone 7 powered smartphone is finally on sale in Finland. What could I do but to try to get my hands on one and report back my findings and experiences. Overall, I'm quite pleased, although I see that a lot must still improve for these devices to hit home in a big way.

 
I managed to get my hands on a black Lumia 800 with a fun lime soft casing. This was the combination I had in mind already when getting the N9, but never really followed it through. Lime turned out to be a great colour that complimented MetroUI's funky and fresh look, although I was left hoping for a little extra punch. Theming WP7 doesn't really exist (out-of-the-box anyway), as you can really only change the colour of the tiles and turn the black background into white. If you want to have more control over customisation, I suggest you get the N9.


Glad to see emphasis is on the aesthetics (again)

I won't spend any time describing the exterior of the device, as its the tried and trusty N9 casing with an extra camera shutter button and a differently placed hole for the flash. Everything about the physical form of the device raises feelings of respect, complimenting the smoothness of WP7. Perhaps even a little more than the same casing did for MeeGo-Harmattan on the N9. WP7 and the casing are a great fit, and the Lumia 800 joins the N9 in the league of devices that bombard the senses with the most pleasant sensations. Bravo, Nokia. Once again.

Even though the customisation options of the operating system on the Lumia 800 are practically 0, the customisation on the N9 is also debatable. Sure you can do all sorts of things in theory, but in practice most people have aimed to keep the core look and feel of MeeGo-Harmattan untouched. And its easy to understand why: MeeGo-Harmattan is a beautiful experience as it is. Windows Phone 7 succeeds in the same feat. Screen items swush, slide and stack on your screen with no stutters or hickups, and soft sounds of the keyboard pat your eardrums with the most pleasant sounds. As a comparisant I regard my HTC DesireZ's system sounds as too interruptive, loud and all around cheap sounding. I think this is true for all Android devices regardless of manufacturer. Leave it to Nokia to spice the ringtone selection up with some familiar sounds and melodies, although Nokia fared much better in this category in its devices from around 3-4 years ago.

Half-baked cakes all around

When comparing to MeeGo-Harmattan, WP7 feels much more finalised which might not come as a surprise to anyone. Everything is in place, nothing feels like a placeholder and a lot of functionality MeeGo-Harmattan seems to go for is already place here. On board the Lumia 800 Nokia ships the latest version of WP7, Windows Phone Mango which hasn't really changed since Tango as I last saw it on the HTC Trophy. Undoubtedly 99% of the new features took place "under hood", which is to be expected anyway in a system so keen on its UI design guidelines.

Windows Phone 7 is by no means, however complete. Funnily enough some gripes I had about MeeGo-Harmattan also apply here. For example, I complained about not being able to adjust font size in the browser on the N9. That really can't be done here either. The second gripe was the refitting of the text to fit your zoom level. This doesn't exist either in WP7 or MeeGo-Harmattan. Also, I was quite fustrated with constantly twisting and turning the device, as only a few applications and functions supported landscape mode. Relating to this, I found it odd that the landscape keyboard doesn't stretch out to invade as much screen real-estate as it could, but instead crammed itself into the middle of the screen. Why is it like this, Microsoft? Is it a resolution thing?

 WP7 makes a big deal about location awareness as well, but sadly the Lumia 800 doesn't know what's around to drink and eat, but will give you locations (that might be restaurants and bars) that you can check in to. This seems like a halfway implemented idea. For some reason my initial response to this was the feeling of being sold a product that doesn't even have all the features it was sold on. Funny I didn't get this feeling with MeeGo.Other similar nigglets include (but aren't limited to) app availability in my region, lack of control over autocorrect functions and missing voice recognition in my language.

The killer thing about Windows Phone 7 for me still seems to be the integration of Facebook and Twitter services into the system. I also happen to agree, that "having an app for that" has very rapidly become part of the problem instead of the solution on smartphone platforms. Having a separate app for everything on an operating system that doesn't support multitasking is just madness. Its like being given all the keys to a huge house, but instructed to close and lock each door after leaving the room, even if just popping out to the kitchen to get a cup of tea before you continue reading your bedtime book. With these smartphone platforms it just never becomes possible to leave a door open. Windows Phone 7 attempts to address this problem by allowing you to view your friends' Facebook images and status updates in your address book, in addition to the traditional options of calling or texting them. This is my number one favourite feature of WP7. Bravo Microsoft.


The many faces of WP7

So just how well does Windows Phone 7 fare against the competition? This is an incredibly difficult question to answer, as WP7 is aimed at people moving up from "dumbphones" to smartphones. This means that functionality in WP7 will be limited, although time will tell how much functionality the ever growing selection of apps for WP7 will bring. WP7 is also strongly stylised and focuses to achieve so tightly defined goals that I imagine it might appear alien or plain unfriendly for some people.

The Lumia 800 comes packed with two great music apps, that really bring life to the entire device in a whole new way. Using the Lumia 800 can be like a visually appealing music video, pulsating with youth and trendiness. The downside to this is that older users force-switching over from Symbian with business purposes in mind might feel like they're getting the raw end of the deal here. Many business users will have their contacts and other data synced to one cloud service or another, but for those moving up from Nokia's pre-Symbian3 phones will have a tough time. At the time of writing this, you can only transfer contacts to WP7 over bluetooth if you have a S3 device. Nokia Suite doesn't work with WP7, and Zune can't manage your personal info on your phone in any way. I don't understand why Nokia was in such a hurry to announce WP7 partnership, only to ship a device so totally incompatible with any previous Nokia devices. Way to piss off loyal customers I think.

I wouldn't be surprised if the reasons described above explain why operators are so sceptical about WP7's chances: business customers don't care how much their phone bill is, but they have to feel they're getting services worth paying for. New smartphone users are a huge target market, but the amount of confusion related to transferring your data over from previous devices might be too much of a hassle, as operators certainly believe customers will return to them for assistance.


Final thoughts

For me WP7 is an opportunity for hedonism, so I choose to enjoy all the things I can about WP7 and not feel so bad about the shortcomings. I'm also lucky to not be really affected by its downsides, as I have all my data in the cloud, and I'm a bit of a social media junkie. So it caters to my needs quite nicely. Comparing to MeeGo-Harmattan, I feel there's more to do on me on this device. The ability to view desktop versions of websites has a big influence on this aspect. Windows Phone 7 is something new and different, albeit incomplete. If I had to describe WP7 in a word: its fresh. Let's see how long this impression lasts.

WP7 is a good choice if you aren't too business or productivity orientated (note: I haven't tried out Office365 yet). We just need to hope that big men Elop and Ballmer won't give out any more ridiculous statements about their own fails with the platform, blaming sales staff or marketing or what have you for bumps in the road. They are in my view the greatest threat right now to the credibility of the platform.

A great testament of this CEO tomfoolery is Elop's promise of bringing "added Nokia value" to this product, which sadly is exactly 0. There's nothing especially Nokian about the software in this product, and that is a truly sad thing to realise. Although the reinvention of Nokia Music's mix radio brings some comfort. The bottom line remains, however: If you see another manufacturer produce a WP7 device with a better screen, processor or some other factor, go for it. You won't be missing out on anything.

Sadly he king no longer stands on its own two feet -- contrary to Elop's promises.

Monday, February 6, 2012

Asus Zenbook UX21 - First few days with it

My Asus Zenbook UX21 arrived yesterday, and its been a great experience so far. I have little experience with Apple products, but the feel of a premium product is created by numerous details both large and small and you are constantly reminded of them.

The problems mentioned in previews regarding the trackpad have all been fixed in the final commercial product, all you have to do is click "Yes" on first boot-up to apply Asus updates. The second gripe previewers had was with the keyboard and there I can see what they might've been talking about. In contrary to previewer's, I would consider the keyboard to be too stiff rather than have too much flex like often reported. We might be describing the same phenomenon, though, as I too suffer from the occasional letter being left out when typing, just like previewers warned. My biggest problem with the keyboard is the placement of the "Del" and "Power" keys right next to eachother. Luckily a custom Asus dialog screen pops up when you press the power key as to make sure you didn't press the key by accident.

Sound from the speakers is very good. I'd still much rather have headphones connected, but for the occasional video viewing they're really great. I can also listen to music if no headphones are available with comfort.


The "instant on" feature is superb, and now a necessity to me on devices as portable as this. Apple people will be more than familiar with this function: it enables the device to come back from hibernation into usable state in around 2 seconds. Just close the lid, pack it away and forget about it. The device has been designed for this use, and so the battery will last for about a week in this state and should the battery run out it will do a quick backup of everything going on so you won't lose your precious work.



Previewers criticized also the viewing angles especially on this 11.6" Zenbook, but I must say that doesn't matter the least to me. I'm glad that the dude sitting next to me on a train won't be able to just gaze over and see what's on my screen. I don't think anyone watches movies off these things, at least not with friends. The screen could be less glossy, but its not as glossy as my old laptop that actually made using it hard in most situations. So again, I'm very content.

Ideally, I would've wanted to get a netbook with built-in 3G,  but soon noticed that these seem to have gone out of fashion. Finnsh operators still have some models in their selection, but I wasn't in the mood of making a 2-year contract just to get my hands on a 3G-enabled device. Luckily my DesireZ and N9 work fantastically as WiFi hotspots, effectively negating the need for a 3G SIM-slot.

Performance wise the machine is great. I'm a big Starcrat 2 fan, and I'm happy to report that SC2 runs decently on Medium settings applied automatically by the game after hardware inspection. If you want to stay on top of what's happening in the game, you might as well switch to "Pro" graphics settings, which means "Low" settings for those unfamiliar with SC2 progaming. ;) Installation of SC2 is always a 2-4 hour feat, as first you download the installer and then you apply all the updates to the game. Thanks to the solid state drive in the UX21, the game installed in record time, clocking just under 3hrs. This is a good hour faster than on my desktop PC. Bravo.

I have no opinion whether this netbook is a "MacBook Air killer" or anything of the sort, but I feel like I've got pretty much everything I would've wanted from the Air and more: premium feel, premium look, but all the app compatibility I could dream of. Not to mention support for accessories: I depend on no single manufactuer for them, everything proprietary has been compensated by Asus by providing the required dongles with the sales package. When comparing the UX21 to other ultrabooks out there right now, Asus fends distinction for itself by the premium design and manufacturing materials. Other ultrabooks at this moment look like plastic toys compared to this thing, even if they cost almost as much as the Zenbook.

Off to install Jolicloud on this thing.





Links to reviews of the Asus Zenbook UX21: 


Anandtech's in-depth review into Ultrabook technology and how the UX21 fares in this regard: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H7YxrWIAVjY

Introduction to the UX21 and a little about the media playback on this device: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IwbOzI4u4ew

UltrabookNews' great written review: http://ultrabooknews.com/2011/11/20/asus-zenbook-ux21e-detailed-review

Saturday, October 22, 2011

From the N900 to the N9, a review






Nokia finally started sales of the N9 mid-October of 2011, and I was lucky to get hold of one for a couple of weeks soon thereafter. Here are my views on the device. I'm a N900 enthusiast and someone who might be called a "power user", so bear this in mind. Please leave a comment after reading if you the least bit feel like doing so.


EDIT: fixes to text made based on readers' comments, thanks so much guys! Oct 23rd
EDIT2: A new firmware upgrade has been released for the N9 to be applied OTA. Twitter, Facebook and various other apps have been upgraded & . Therefore info in this article might be outdated. -- 9.11.11.


MeeGo UI:


Let's start with the most interesting, the User Interface. The N9 is quite a different experience to Maemo (or Android for that matter) as it has no "desktop", but a "three views" -system where you see your apps, events and open applications in views adjacent to eachother. A key component in the UI is the swipe gesture, with which you swipe between these views, shoo away open apps and even close them. There are no "X" icons hanging about, just swipe, swipe, swipe.


Perhaps the most dominant of the views is the apps-list, which received some criticism from me as soon as I saw it in a leaked video. I understood that this kind of "app listing" view was deemed obsolete by Marko Ahtisaari in a conference about Nokia's design ideas (Link, thanks "Anonymous"!), but apparently he really only meant that they thought the iPhone home button was the only thing worth changing there. Windows Phone 7 is in this sense more advanced in design-language I think, as the starting page tiles represent a new kind of approach to using your device. Be what it may design-wise, all your apps will add to the app-list view, with no options for making folders or groups. This appears to be coming in the next update. Thanks to a reader for the tip!




The swipe is however very smooth, where you're able to gradually swipe away a playing video or any other app in action, see what's in the view beneath it and then choose to drag the video back to full screen or shoo it away. This is an example of the sheer technical brilliance Nokia has packed this device with. This is an industry first, but something tells me we're going to see more of it. The N9 doesn't run on the very latest hardware, but features like this make Android feel bloated and messy in comparisant to this kind of smooth, immediate performance --on "dated" hardware. Bravo, Nokia! "It's not technology, its what you do with it" applies here.




Software decisions


The experience on the N9 is very good  and the "3 views" style UI works brilliantly. There are no stutters, and even devices running with almost full memory continue to function smoothly (for the most part). However, some of the design decisions on the software side bother me. I never quite feel as in control over my running apps as I do on the N900, because sometimes a same direction swipe means changing between playing songs, viewing pictures or sending the app to the background. Granted, this will only get better and better as you use it more and more, and will probably be refined in software updates to come.


My biggest gripe with the software, however are the native apps and the browser. The Facebook and Twitter apps open a drastically simplified app of what we're all probably used to. Perhaps this is also due to it being an early software version. On the other hand, they're stylistically so simplified, that I can't help but fear that it is part of the design choice and won't be altered. Or in Nokia fashion its "left to the community to fix" but at the same time they're closed source apps. Please correct me if they are in fact open source! Most of the pages in the stock browser open up as mobile websites by default (if someone knows how to tweak this, let me know!) and pages won't let you change to the full site, probably because of the lack of support for Flash. In worst cases sites offer you to change from "Simplified mobile" to "Text based version". Hrrr, 600€ for a text version of Facebook? This reminds me too much of that other product. Granted this could be due to websites not fully recognizing the N9 yet, or a premature browser software version.




Browser king?


To dwell into the browser issue more, the browser experience is perhaps one of the two biggest dissapointments for me about the N9. One big reason to why the N900 is such a timeless device is its browser. Everything is moving towards web apps, so why not perfect a near perfect browser and thus future-proof the phone? The answer to this is probably in switching over to MeeGo's browser that doesn't and probably will not support Flash, and so its basically a completely different browser to MicroB found on the N900. As Anidel points out in the comments, however, technically it is in a sense very advanced, but until sites decide to make full use of it, it leaves a simple impression.


Totally in-line with the rest of the native apps, the browser is missing some basic functionality. For example, clearing your browsing history is not (at least at the moment) possible inside the browser (thanks for correction) the saving or clearing of passwords is not present, and it doesn't even have bookmarks and making bookmarks could be a bit more intuitive. The browser tries to form "tags" around what you've browsed to or searched on the web, which I couldn't find much use for. Also, this tag system is not incredibly accurate either. For some reason my first search for the nearest swimming halls remains huge in the "tags" and I've only done the search once. Unfortunately also the e-mail app is also lacking in some features that people probably expect to be there by default. For me it was OK, though, I get along with the N900's e-mail app just fine, so I'm probably not so needy as some of you guys.


The browser is also suffering from some text-entry box related oddness I remember first spotting in the earliest MeeGo Developer Edition releases. When tapping on a text box, the view zooms too close to it, the virtual keyboard blocks a huge part of the text box plus the text box isn't completely visible. The end result is that you have to type blind. Pinch-zooming will only confuse the browser more. Sites where I saw this happen were Maemo.org and TweetGo.net.


All in all, though, the performance of the applications on the N9 is superb, Nokia Store might not be filled to brim with apps but makes up for it in quality and stutters of Nokias' past is nowhere to be seen here. It seems that first apps in the Nokia Store have really caught on to the design style of Nokia's MeeGo-Harmattan, and together with the phone UI they make up a wonderful experience.




The Achille's heel


The next thing I'm going to rant about will probably not even matter for 90% of people the N9 is aimed for, but its a showstopper for me. I think you've been waiting for this remark all review long: the N9 doesn't have a hardware keyboard. And it Sucks. Nuts.


It sucks Nuts.


I tried and I tried, but a VKB (virtual keyboard) just can't keep up with me and just can't satisfy my needs. A lot of people seem to get on fine with their touch-only text-entry keyboards, but nobody can pull off sending a SMS with more complex contents than "OK" when on the run. Also, I enter a lot of text on my N900, part of this blog entry is written on my N900. The N900 is my main device for reading and replying to e-mail, I Twitter more on my N900 than on my desktop, and I use IM more on my N900 than on my desktop PC. And I'm also a kind of a blabbermouth of a guy. So it simply infuriates me when a device forces me to get down on my knees and only send "OK" messages around to my friends if I don't have 5-10mins to stop and tap in letters for a message. Swype should be making an appearance in the first software update to the N9. Sadly I doubt that it will allow me to write messages on the run any better.


One thing I must make clear though: the N9's virtual keyboard is NOT a bad virtual keyboard. Nokia's keyboards on Symbian³ are terrible. They're rubbish. The virtual keyboard on the N9 is, ironically, in my view one of the most aesthetically pleasing aspects about the device. The keyboard click sound, combined with the haptic feedback and beautiful screen makes for a wonderful experience. It is the most pleasurable virtual keyboard out there and is perhaps the crucial feature about this device that gives it its premium feel. Expect this to be imitated in competitors' devices.






N9 & the competition


Since the launch of the iPhone Nokia's devices have all been pitted against the iPhone, regardless if these devices have actually targeted the same audience. The N9 however (finally) has an air about it that makes it seem as if it aims to take on the iPhone. This is noticeable from the wy the N9 focuses heavily on user experience, in the good and the bad. 


It seems the N9 was designed with the rule-of-thumb to favour user experience over functionality. INo think this explains the rudimentariness of the stock apps. My guess is functionality is missing in fear of cluttering up the UI. 


The N9 also seems to carry a bit of a grudge over from experiences with people and media criticising the landscape-only orientation of the N900. The N9 strikes back by allowing portrait mode everywhere, but sadly it over-compensates just a little bit. Most of the stock apps, such as the mentioned Facebook and Twitter apps don't rotate to landscape orientation --at all. Not even when you're inserting text. So the portrait qwerty is all you get. Trying to work around this problem is browsing to the website, but then you have to face the shortcomings of the browser.


In general I think the main guideline for the experience was the iPhone, at least in mentality: everything must look good, but there's no way to get to the nitty-gritty and no customizability. This made me feel at times like I'd been thrown back to 2007. On the other hand however, using the N9 is aesthetically an incredibly pleasant experience. The way it feels in your hand, the sounds and graphics add up to a very pristine and classy experience. Not to mention the effect of the VKB. 


Compared to the N9, the iPhone feels like a lifeless and cold slab of metal and glass that you tap and pat. That's it. The N9 responds to every tap, connects with your natural way of doing things, and constantly rewards you for using the device. There's no eye-candy here per se, just grace and intuitiveness. So yeah, the N9 is a better phone than the iPhone.





Final comments



The N9 exceeds in everything it sets out to accomplish and even beats the competition in their own game, so you can't really say its a bad device. What's important to realize here is, that the N9 is in no way a successor of the N900, even if its initial efforts might've been to that direction. The mobile Linux enthusiast is better off somewhere else (but where?).


The N9 led me to realise that there are now two manufacturers in the game that know how to combine what you feel in your hands with what you hear and see to form a comprehensive, wholesome aesthetic experience. And in this sense, the Nokia N9 manages to surpass the iPhone by a hundred miles. It's great to be able to say this about a Nokia device. 


The N9 might not ever have the apps the iPhone has, but all in all at this time, the Nokia N9 is a better device than the iPhone for that crowd that appreciates the iPhone to begin with. If, however you are looking for something along the lines of the N900, the N9 isn't the device for you. If you decide to go for the N9 anyway, many familiar Maemo apps are available in the Nokia Store, such as: Filebox, Twimgo and gPodder.


There's a software update coming to the N9 from Nokia soon, so a lot of what I ranted about might be changed. I try to remind myself also of the fact, that the N9 runs on MeeGo and I know there's a hacker community around this device that will let the rest of us in on tweaking the insides of this device. For me personally though, no amount of modifying the N9 will bring me a hardware keyboard. Without a hardware keyboard, I feel the N9 is only holding me back, not setting me free.




R.I.P.






Do you agree/disagree? Please leave a comment below.


Thanks for reading,
Chris